Hopefully we can get some steem for watching ads, similar to what @partiko has done.

Posted using Partiko Android

I think it also might be interesting in looking into giving authors which get a lot of people to see/click adds a share of the ad revenue. Would definitely get people to announce steem more loudly outside of the crypto space.

This would be an interesting change

Would also encourage authors to be more engaging in their own posts..

Great idea! Thanks for sharing

Yes, indeed. However, I think one should not just count the number of upvotes, but the number of comments (or maybe even better: comments on comments) under the articles to judge how many real readers an author attracts (bots aren't very interested in reading advertisements).

Ads have pros and cons, as I'm sure you know better than do I.

Some negatives not commonly understood, however, are the potential for ads to be means to launder money, or to capture a platform and essentially hold it hostage. Advertisers wielding nominal stake with care can make a platform dependent on their funds.

While this seems unlikely on Steem, various malignancies can result even if the dependency is apparently less than total, or even seems minimal.

There are platforms today that only persist in operations due to their essential captivity to specific advertisers/communities. If certain emoluments feature in executive pay mechanisms, platforms that are losing money are still able to be abused, and such abuse concealed from investors.

There are very sophisticated players in the advertising market. Not a few of them are much different than what they seem.

I was happy to get out of that line of work. Do undertake specific care regarding covert attack vectors that advertisers may seek to employ to increase the influence they wield across Steem. It may be trivial, or only appear trivial, at the outset.

The game can be pretty savage, and the successful players are brutal. It is inadvisable for me to go into specific detail here regarding various hazards I became aware of prior to leaving that field, but some of them were existential.

Fair warning.

Without a doubt some folks would find them more palatable given that feature.

Perhaps too palatable.

I'd like to see how that actually worked out. It's a great idea.

Thanks!

As this is a second question, what about SMTs? What about the previously posted roadmap regarding it? News about them were pretty thin lately.

+1 Looking for info on SMTs and how to get an SMT name

Came here to ask the same thing. Seems Steemit are more focused on saving money than delivering crucial features. What they don't seem to realise is, if they deliver SMT's the price of Steem is going to skyrocket, therefore easing the financial burden they have right now. It's a catch twenty-two.

they were paying too much for servers to run the websites of all dapps. Cost reduction became prority for the company to surive. They are dramatically reducing cost and making some revenue from ads.

Once they are financially stable, they will work on SMTs.

Cost reduction is great, but you can work on multiple things at once. It seems to be taking them an unusually large amount of time to split out the wallet from the Condenser application let alone other things, which signals to me a couple of things:

• The development team is lacking needed resources
• There might be a disparity between skill level, during downsizing they might have let go more experienced (by proxy, more expensive) developers which meant they were left with only a few developers familiar with the more intricate underlying pieces. This means that there are probably pieces of the Steem architecture that realistically, only one or two developers can change
• The Condenser app is messy, while it is broken up into individual components, it is still tightly coupled and difficult to work with. This seems to be a problem that many React applications share once they go beyond a few components

I think STINC is still in its infancy. From the outset anyone who can see things holistically, if Steemit had delivered on their promise of SMT's, they wouldn't have needed to experiment with advertisements. I can almost guarantee that they would make more than enough revenue from charging fees associated with the creation of a new token.

A great example of the demand is the work @aggroed and his team have done with @steem-eng which just launched its new DEX yesterday. Quite a few tokens have been created already, and while it is a sidechain, it delivers on the promise of creating your own token and it serves most use-cases. They're working on a consensus layer which will only put it further ahead.

The real problem here is: STINC is blind to their own community. There are so many capable and experienced developers who want to help Steem grow. Steemit Inc has more than enough liquid Steem to spend a few hundred thousand to fund community contribution and grow the blockchain. If Steemit let the community handle SMT's with financial incentives, they would probably be done by now.

Thanks for stating some insightful and valid thoughts. I note that @steemalliance is addressing your last point, perhaps differently than you'd recommend, but it is being undertaken.

Steem Engine is pretty cool.

Going forward, the number of dapps is going to increase at unknown, but probably accelerating rates, and poorly tuned nodes would have multiplied that burden obscenely.

It's impossible to state fees from SMTs would be able to provide more substantial funding, as there is practically no experience with such a product. Like Steem, SMTs are novel technology, and difficult to accurately price, or analyze for costs and benefits.

Most of us are convinced (I am) that SMTs are gonna be homerun financially, but if they come out flawed, they're gonna be a nightmare instead. I am encouraged that Stinc hasn't just rushed something out and started flailing away at bugs, flaws, and disappointment, as @drugwars has, for example.

I'm presently almost convinced that in the long run decreasing the expense of running nodes and encouraging dapps to run their own may actually be more critical to the success of Steem than SMTs.

Nodes are the key to decentralization, and if costs can continue to come down while computer capacity continues to increase, eventually extremely robust decentralization will be able to protect the blockchain from threats regardless of their source.

Nothing is more important than security from existential threat.

Lastly, I cannot judge your competence, but things are not always just what they seem to be, and it is often useful to consider the quality of optics with which one regards things. There may be extremely important reasons for specific undertakings being priority over others, and we just can't know without more information than is availed us.

Thanks!

Appics is a great project and was depending on the SMT's being done this March. Now, they might leave to EOS because of these leaders have small vision and don't know how to set priorities.

Who cares if it's backend node crap is cheaper if all the projects are gone???

Steem will always be faster and lower cost than a general purpose blockchain like EOS. People are free to go to other blockchains, especially if their priority is short term financial gains that sacrifice long term usability. But those projects that do will fail because they will have to pass on their costs to the end user.

Who cares if some dapps lose patience and go to EOS? They'll be back when they see that EOS isn't fit for purpose yet. If they don't come back, I don't care because Steem needs people that have a bit of patience and can plan for the long term. Pretending everything is working, just to get a short term spike in the price is the wrong strategy, there's lots of other cryptos doing that. Perhaps more people should try using EOS, they've had a lot of problems and I'm sure that's not going to change fast. Most of their dapps are junk as well, there's only 1 that I like using, unlike Steem that has many good dapps now.

Well said. Which of their apps do you like using?

@andrarchy

Karma is pretty decent UI lately, mobile and supports Video. Getting much use in? AFRICA
Nigeria seems the future to me! 200 MIL smart, hard working people that have no job prospects and will have to devote themselves to becoming blockchain entrepreneurs.

>>People are free to go to other blockchains, especially if their priority is short term financial gains that sacrifice long term usability.

You should not be in PR, you should be behind a desk punching numbers and never have to talk to people. Your company released dates for SMTs launch sometime last year and shelved the project without an official statement or reason and this is what you have to angry disappointed people?

People trusted and have been waiting on you for over a year and just look at the tone with which you say the nonsense you say. Steemit should own up to it's shortcomings.

I think the answer is above in that they must avoid spreading themselves too thinly which leads to not being able to complete cost related development that will help the underlying sustainability of the protocol and its infrastructure. They may have also been seeing the alternatives to SMT spreading and will likely have to take then into consideration when the time comes.

Posted using Partiko iOS

SMT's are nowhere in their priorities right now. Steemit Inc is fighting for survival right now. We're not getting even a whiff of SMT's before 2020, and only then if crypto markets skyrocket.

word

Posted using Partiko Android

I don't think they're still at the "survival" stage anymore, but that'd just be a guess after recent price changes and since they sell the same amount of coins monthly. About SMT's, @steem-engine lauched recently so people can get their coins going already and when SMT's come around to give those coins blockchain level curation, etc, we'll be waiting with a healthy distribution through markets and the way dapps are already distributing their tokens.

Don't wait for Steemit, Inc to do this. Check out Steem Engine, a DEX marketplace created by the devs who made Steem Monsters.

We are committed to getting back to SMTs as soon as possible, that being said, I think Steem Engine is super cool and people should definitely check it out. Soft Consensus is Steem's secret killer app

We are definitely trying to get back to SMTs as fast as possible. It's not at all true that we are giving up on that project. The fact of the matter is that our work on MIRA is just more important now, and it's not possible to know exactly how long that work will take. It could be a week, it could be a month, we just don't know and aren't willing to pretend we do. Once we're done with MIRA, SMTs is high up on the to-do list.

MIRA is not more important that SMT's. As you can see, people are dying to build DAPS but your not giving them the tools. Those same people will leave to EOS or other blockchains. Mira is nice backend crap, but will not attract people to stay and build.

https://i.gifer.com/WRGa.gif

I'm not surprised people don't understand why MIRA is so critical, and that means we should do a better job with education, but MIRA is absolutely necessary prior to SMTs because it is a scaling solution. The cost of running steemd nodes is just too damn high. Period. MIRA will move the blockchain from RAM (expensive) to commodity hardware (cheap). This will dramatically lower the cost of running a node, which most dapp developers do. There's a reason why the only dapps people actually use are on the Steem blockchain, and it's because we solve the hard problems, not the sexy problems. People can waste their time building apps on other platforms, but the moment they get any traction, they'll realize they're screwed because their costs are going to go through the roof. We expect SMTs to dramatically increase the number of transactions happening on our blockchain (which are already extremely high) and so while MIRA will help every node operator (including witnesses) in the short run, it will also be extremely beneficial for ensuring a positive user experience once SMTs launch. It's solutions like MIRA that are actually doing the heavy lifting with respect to maintaining our significant lead over other projects in the space who aren't solving the REAL problems. They aren't capable of understanding what those problems are because they don't have real apps with real users operating in real time like we do.

Thank you @andrarchy ...

> "... people don't understand why MIRA is so critical, and that means we should do a better job with education ..."

... for taking the time to educate us on the importance of MIRA. While my relatively small stake doesn't "speak" very loudly, I for one am all in favor of "doing it right the first time" rather than rushing through and dealing with all of the fallout of not ...

One of my favorite sayings (from an ~~old~~ "mature" engineer ...):

> "If you don't have time to do it right, when will you have time to do it over?"
>
> John Wooden, Legendary Basketball Coach of UCLA

I was pretty upset about the going on of the past three months or so but, ultimately, Steem and Steem dApps are some of the best things to hit the internet since it's inception.

Despite some major errors and kerfuffles you guys seem to be working hard to right the ship. Good on you.

Question: can we expect to see communities by the end of 2019?

I appreciate you sticking with us through these challenging times. We're eager to get back to working on Communities and much of that work is already done. I want to see Communities in that time frame, and I think it can be done, but it's outside the scope of what we are currently working on so we aren't able to commit to anything. That being said, after completing the cost reduction measures that are our current priority (and which are going better than expected), Communities and SMTs are at the top of the to-do list.

Thanks for the really quick response.

It very encouraging to see this level of genuine communication and engagement with the community. I think that moving forward this could become as a positive point of distinction when comparing Steemit to other platforms within this space. Congratulations on the recent accomplishments and continued success.

Thanks for the update! It is great feeling that the platform one is deeply invested in is progressing inexorably into a spectacular future.

Thanks!

When are SMT's going to be completed?

You guys made a commitment to having this done in early 2019 and projects were literally depending on that deadline. Do you guys even understand the impact? Those projects, which would make STEEM look good, are now leaving to EOS or other blockchains.
https://media.giphy.com/media/H9bn1yn9ScQ6s/giphy.gif

Steem still has the best dapps and they can use this now https://steem-engine.com/

I am excited for you to be able to finish up work on the back end stuff!

Including ads was a good move. @partiko have taken that to the next level by rewarding partiko points for viewing ads. It will be interesting to find out the number of views these ads are getting in a few weeks time.

Appreciate the update.
1 - What is the reasoning for splitting the condenser into two separate applications? I don't think this is a good direction, and adds additional complexity by eventually forcing new users to extract their posting keys for signing in to the separate social app. This slows down the signup process and will cause a drop in user activation. This also will require all users to only be able to easily access the social app on a browser with a password manager, otherwise they will need to copy and paste this key. A SteemConnect login option may alleviate this.

While I agree that the wallet needs improvements, such as a more clearly designated send button and a cleaner address-book for contacts, splitting it out and forcing posting key only is a step in the wrong direction for UX.

2 - Could you elaborate on how you plan to use Steemit's ad program to benefit all app developers? Would you consider burning STEEM with a portion of earned revenue?

3 - At any time, has the Steemit UI development team considered improving the already built in promoted post system to feature these posts embedded in other feeds to drive visibility? This feature has been superseded by bid bots, which currently deliver cost-less post promotion, as rewards cover promotion payments. The Steem blockchain can capture more of this value by better optimizing the promoted post system.

4 - At any time, has the Steemit UI team considered adding a tip button to posts for sending a fast payment directly to a content creator?
To see an example of this, check out https://alpha.weyoume.io, currently operating on a STEEM based testnet.

All the best. -Haz

[IMAGE: https://cdn.steemitimages.com/DQmaGMhyeGv7zz8j5bgcYGu6sbxvZLBWdR6UikkoNNXMz3B/image.png]

source https://goo.gl/images/tmbZL8

I am going to do this to every post that is censored as it is the only way to get my harmless content seen. I have been left no other choice and see this as the only solution. Every post that is unfairly downvoted for no good reason by not just one or two accounts but hundreds of them all owned by the same person will be re-posted hundreds of times. You want to waste your money abusing someone who has done nothing to you. Let's see you combat 100 of each version of the posts you censor. This must be done in protest of this abuse. @steemit @ned

The people of Steem as wonderful as many of them are live in fear of speaking out against this type of communist abuse. You all can be seen on Twitter ranting and raving about how wonderful #STEEM is and inviting everyone to join this 'Free Speech' paradise. Yet all of you know you have no real free speech. You either 'agree' with the bullies.. or feel the lash of the pharoahs whip and be on the receiving end of the absolute abuse of censorship.

If they don't like you. What you stand for. Or who you are.. they simply wipe you out with downvotes aka censorship. There is no order, total lawlessness, and zero democracy.

Not one of you will leave a message giving your honest opinion on the dictatorship/censorship/and abuse of the accounts who hold the most Steem.

You think this platform has free speech? I dare you to make a video addressing this problem and the elephant in the room. You won't because you know you can kiss it goodbye if you have an opinion.

@ned your platform needs to have order and freedom. The downvote option is for true abuse. For example if someone uploads a stolen film from Universal Studios etc. As you well know and don't seem to care the abuse of the downvote option and it will be the death of your platform.

I will now make sure the whole world knows about this post and the censorship/dictatorship abuse happening on Steem. I also am in the talks with CNN as well as Fox News.

Unfortunately this topic needs to be brought to the light.

Steem is run amok with people whom have larger wallets and seek to act as the thought police.

Should Hitler be alive right now and have bought an account on Steem and loaded it with massive money.. like wise if you were the wrong race, the wrong religion, or had opinions he did not like you can bet your buttons you would be kept at the bottom of the barrel. What is happening right now is no different. This is not censorship based on rules broken we can all mutually agree on. This is absolute harassment and abuse of the downvote option.

Want to show us your free speech? I dare you to try.

-You will either stay quiet

-Agree with the harasser (in fear of being on the end of his lash)

-Or have a voice and loose your account

[IMAGE: https://cdn.steemitimages.com/DQmStMvHhy6mQGHk8UHd7kj3FoQniLVvAQq6hd9jbQuRRJc/image.png]

source https://goo.gl/images/m41frx

The sad truth is none of us are any better than slaves on the Steem blockchain. If you dare speak up or have a voice you will be violently harassed. Financially harassed. You will even have your name smeared in the public square.

I would never do what I am about to do. This is my only way to be heard in my protest of this abuse of the rights of others to freedom.

THE TRUTH ABOUT @kawaiicrush:@kawaiicrush is a whack job who was posting manipulated photos of her 10 year old daughter, pretending they were herself, in order to attract men. How disgusting can a mother possibly be?Now since speaking out about her, since she is absolutely OBSESSED with me and spends her entire day manually posting and commenting about me in order to try and troll me.What a pathetic, sad life you live @kawaiicrush. Maybe you should spend time with that daughter of yours rather than worrying so much about approval from others on the internet, but, we're all used to seeing you exploit your daughter so this isn't surprising.CLICK HERE FOR THE FULL STORY