This is a response to a comment on my article here on sexual clickbait.
http://i68.tinypic.com/2ela7hd.jpg
Are we asking for it?
@cogliostro has a strange answer to that question.
>Ladies, in the wild, in lawless conditions with no police - you need to cover up, because otherwise you will get raped all the time by horny men.
Covering up helps a decent woman only get raped some of the time, not constantly and not by everyone. It helps her gain favor with the other females, who are less likely to see her as a "slut" and unfair competition. The decent men of the tribe are inspired by this, and often are willing to give their lives to protect the decent women from all dangers, all rapists, domestic and international.
In his opinion women wear clothes in order to protect themselves from the ever so daunting and oppressive nature of males. He claims that if we didn’t, we’d ”get raped all the time.” This is both shocking and curious.
When I asked myself the above question, “why do we wear clothes?” I came up with several very different answers. Perhaps I’m too cold or too hot, want to cover up, or shield myself from mosquitos.
He has a pretty strange ideology, but I continued to read anyway.
>That is the origin of our "oppressive" custom to dress modestly, and not spread your legs for the public in wantonly, tawdry self-glorification.
Here is where it starts to become a rollercoaster...
Restricting Women’s Freedom
http://i66.tinypic.com/2j0nwix.jpg
>Does it restrict women's freedom to bar them from such cheap thrills? Sure. But so what?
Telling women what and what not to wear is restrictive, but it isn’t to bar them from cheap thrills-- it bars us from expressing ourselves.
In my opinion, women should be able to wear whatever they want. Hell, they could be naked for all I care (as long as it’s abiding local laws or they’re indoors). Regardless, it does not excuse rape, and the perpetrator should be held accountable for their actions.
“One of the basic tenants of the United States Constitution is freedom of expression. If a woman makes a choice to wear a short skirt or go bra-less she had the God given and Constitutional right to do without harassment or fear of bodily harm.” (debate.org)
Where it gets scary
>Police restricts men's freedom too. Common decency restricts men's freedom even further, as far as their interaction with women.
>As you pretend not to know (but I know you know), men have a biological reflex, they get a hard dick from seeing your wondrous feminine charms and men always want to fuck - often when you don't.
This is terrifying.
I’m familiar with biological urges. I have them, as well. But I also have self control.
Surely, this isn’t a valid excuse for modern misbehavior.
Do men really feel this way?
>If you want men to magically be "OK" with it, to ignore everything they were evolved to do and be, then you will end up destroying men and you will be left utterly miserable on your own with other miserable women. You can't push and push indefinitely, dangling sex in front of men's faces like a scarlet cloth in front of a raging bull, without experiencing a pushback that will send you flying, and land you right on your naive ass in the middle of ridiculously unfavorable circumstances you never bargained for or deserved.
His last sentence is possibly the only one that is remotely agreeable to me.
“Ridiculously unfavorable circumstances you never bargained for or deserved” is damn right. Being harassed or raped is never deserved.
The rest of it is absolutely toxic, though.
>We hope you go back to being your sweet, unpretentious and modest selves very soon, inspiring us to see you as the treasured and cherished mother of our future unborn children... not as a fuck doll to be used by every Jack and Joe. And that you discard this silly blue hair diversion you misguidedly call "empowerment" forever.
Lovingly yours,
The Good Men.
This is one of the things that motivates me as an activist. Some people still think that it’s okay to blame the victim, or that it’s okay to control and manipulate people to fit their standards.
His entire letter is an apologist perspective on rape.
I’m trying very hard to be objective, but it is nearly impossible with this one. I disagree with this because it denies women basic rights and freedoms.
Empowerment is different for everyone, and sure, sometimes it’s defined by what we wear. But that is never an excuse to mistreat or tell anyone what to do.
A “good man” is respectful.
Stop telling women what to wear, and stop telling women how to not get raped.
Thanks for reading. Question and discuss.
xoxo Vera
@veralynn and to counterpoint that.
If we should be teaching men to act like men, then should we not also be teaching women to act like women?
How about just teaching people to be human?
But you have to ask yourself what that means.
Why teach people any sort of "gender role"?
Very few people in the world are actually "indecent" human beings. But you'll find that here in the real world, indecency when it occurs which is rather rare, is neither gender nor race specific.
It's more to do with class. The flaming troll attacking you has none, they were brought up without someone giving them some sort of attention that they craved. So they are here getting it instead. My guess is this is coming from a child of a broken home, likely daddy issues.
>Yes men it looks like one of us dropped the ball on this one and this is what happens when we do. So watch it and make sure you're there for them every time they need you or you get this.
But consider this. Some people are just provocateurs and will stop at nothing to portray their enemy in a negative light. Even if that means assuming the role of the enemy. Wearing their skin as it were.
So knowing that, I'm curious as to why you believe that the person who posted this was actually male?
It's so full of stereotypes, it comes off to me as more likely to be a female because, I mean come on guys, it's portraying outright rape which is a control issue as though it were purely a sexual issue.
My money is on the person who wrote the diatribe being a woman in her 30s to mid 40s trying to deal with rape fantasies she's either had or read about. Check the article I linked, I know it's long as hell but read the whole thing, because she's parroting it. Then using said fantasies to lash out by roleplaying a male.
It's more than the sexualization of rape culture though. Men and women are in fact hard wired a bit differently by nature in ways that come across in our communications and cannot be overidden for long by nuture no matter how hard they try.
Just sayin, seems obvious to me. It's #gamergateredux
This is some epic level master of puppets stuff going on though.
Not playing this game.
I'm outtie.
Come find me when we're highlighting good people again.
Even having the back ground of these conversations, it just hurt my head. I had to go back and read it a second time.
The way I read his argument is that he has an extremely low view of men. Except for himself.
Men have Overwhelming sexual urges towards women, RAWR!!! Except for him.
Men either can't or don't want to control these urges, RAWR! Except for him.
Women that don't take some measures, whether it be wearing clothes or lock
themselves (or the men) in cages, increase the likelihood that the women will be raped. RAWR!
[Many women in tribes, such as the Dogon, are topless, yet not much of a rape issue.]
In modern society, rape is shunned as much as racism. While these arguments may of held in pre-civilization (when clothing was still worn by the way) there has been a relatively consistent trend by society as a WHOLE to agree that rape is bad. While this by no means says that it never occurs, the act itself is deplorable to just about anybody.
Have respect for the men! Look at how far the human race has come from Socrates and Plato to Einstien and @team-leibniz. There is no way to argue that rape, assault, hate or other blatant forms of human disrespect are acceptable. From ANYONE!
While there is plenty of discussion to the general psychology and tendencies that grew from evolutionary biology, this argument just doesn't make sense. Nobody argues that we are the same as cave men. We hold ourselves as a the current human race to a higher standard. If you're trying to honestly equate men getting horny by looking at porn, clickbait or sexualized advertising to a justification for why ALL women need to do ANYTHING...I just don't buy it. There isn't a core argument that ties your beginning and ends together.
Next you'll be telling me that because the Easter bunny is covered in polka dots the sky is falling.
Let's all just agree to hold ourselves to a higher standard of respect and discourse.
*mic drop
I've chosen your post to respond, as I've detected genuine thought going on - an attempt to understand what you're facing. Thank you kindly, and it's my pleasure to now show that there was indeed a core argument, which you regrettably missed.
As you know, my post was itself a response to another discussion. That discussion was about how "women should do whatever they want with their sexuality". I pointed out that the restrictions that classical cultures place on women are not arbitrary, they arise from social necessity. Female sexuality is not the only player on the block, there is also male sexuality which must be considered & taken into account.
Women sexually flaunting themselves to men who cannot do anything about it - that is a recipe for disaster.
Veralynn may not know it, but her feminism is meant to lead to disaster. It is meant to destroy the fabric of society, like a nerve poison.
This type of feminism is all about maximally unrestricted female sexuality with maximally restricted male sexuality.
"I should be able to wave the scarlet cloth in front of the bull's face and be safe, this is my safe space!"
Good, good - but only as long as there are men with guns and gavels, who provide you with the physical and legal protection you need for your exercise in unrestricted female sexuality ("empowerment"). As soon as these artificial protections are whisked away, you either instantly become a decent woman who covers up and is careful about opening her mouth too much around strange men, or you careen into a complete trainwreck - becoming a serial victim to any lawless men around, who will treat you like human trash.
Being a decent woman and not provoking men sexually is in effect a kind of insurance policy, which makes it more likely that other men will protect you if bad situations happen, and other women view you more favorably (somebody worth defending).
One does get the distinct impression though, that I am talking to children. Children who think "I should be able to have all the candies I want!!", and are ill equipped to understand the concept of dental caries, or the loss of smiles and health it brings.
http://i.imgur.com/EkW3a4l.jpg
@veralynn
It appears you were just attacked. If you read what the attacker is saying, they are blaming you, specifically for their own feelings.
The entire debate is moot because nudity and sexuality have nothing to do with eachother.
I highly recommend you checkout AANR
Lowest incidence of rape in the world is at nudist resorts.
Male or female, you simply cannot get aroused when everyone around you is naked.
So pretty much all arguments relating decency to the clothing you wear will fall apart right there.
Second argument.. Rape is sexual.
Which is actually the core of the question "Are you asking for it?"
It misses the point. Predators hunt prey. This person is expressing the views of a predator. Views that I can only hope they are taking to this extreme because they are attempting to portray a character. If not then they need mental health help.
Rape is not sexual, it has nothing to do with the act of sex.
The truth is so much worse and that's why the damage is so lasting.
People that force unwanted encounters, do so for the control.
When they get off on it, it's not the sex act giving them gratification. It's the fact that they successfully forced their will on someone else. They feel like their own life is out of control and therefore other people don't matter.
They believe they must assert control by forcing someone to submit to them.
This is exactly the same motive that pyromaniacs, spousal abusers, stalkers, rapists and even psychopaths have. A loss of their "locus of control", drives this behavior. Control is what provides them with a sense of gratification.
Like I said in @lauralemon 's post where she dealt with someone oddly similar
People that think this way are in dire need of competent, qualified, mental health help. That's where this comes from.
My final thoughts...
Notice my absolute lack of gender specific pronouns and my specific use of "they, them, their". This was intentional but not for the reason you think.
Your attacker is neither truly male, nor are they sincere, nor are they rational at the moment. They have painted a cariacature specifically in order to provoke a response.
In the meantime they have managed to paint a negative view of a legitimate men's rights organization but to the players in this game it's just collateral damage.
Welcome to gamergate 2.0
Same advice to everyone who sees this.
For some games, the best way to win is not to play.
Upvote if you agree, argue if you think I'm wrong.
here is another polite attempt to get along with you Vera,
what do you think about this song?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Me85PztkYP0
If you walk away I walk away
First tell me which road you will take
I don't want to risk our paths crossing someday
So you walk that way I'll walk this way
And the future hangs over our heads
And it moves with each current event
Until it falls all around like a cold steady rain
Just stay in when it's lookin' this way
And the moon's laying low in the sky
Forcing everything metal to shine
And the sidewalk holds diamonds like a jewelry store case
They argue "Walk this way", "No, walk this way"
And Laura's asleep in my bed
As I'm leaving she wakes up and says
"I dreamed you were carried away on the crest of a wave
Baby, don't go away, come here"
And there's kids playing guns in the street
And one's pointing his tree branch at me
So I put my hands up I say
"Enough is enough, if you walk away I walk away"
(And he shot me dead)
I found a liquid cure
For my landlocked blues
It will pass away like a slow parade
It's leaving but I don't know how soon
And the world's got me dizzy again
You'd think after twenty-two years I'd be used to the spin
And it only feels worse when I stay in one place
So I'm always pacing around or walking away
I keep drinking the ink from my pen
And I'm balancing history books up on my head
But it all boils down to one quotable phrase
If you love something give it away
A good woman will pick you apart
A box full of suggestions for your possible heart
But you may be offended and you may be afraid
But don't walk away, don't walk away
We made love on the living room floor
With the noise in the background from a televised war
And in the deafening pleasure I thought I heard someone say
If we walk away, they'll walk away
But greed is a bottomless pit
And our freedom's a joke we're just taking a piss
And the whole world must watch the sad comic display
If you're still free start runnin' away
'Cause we're comin' for ya
I've grown tired of holding this pose
I feel more like a stranger each time I come home
So I'm making a deal with the devils of fame
Sayin' let me walk away, please
You'll be free child once you have died
From the shackles of language and measurable time
And then we can trade places, play musical graves
Till then walk away, walk away, walk away, walk away
So I'm up at dawn, putting on my shoes
I just want to make a clean escape
I'm leaving but I don't know where to
I know I'm leaving but I don't know where to